Andy Irons & Kelly Slater had some amazing battles over the years, up towards the top was this final at the 2005 Billabong J-Bay event.

On the last wave of the heat Kelly stroked into a wave needing a 9.25 to win it... did he get it?.. the judges thought so giving him a 9.50 and the rest is history. The debate still goes on weather he got the score, what do you think? either way it's what makes our sport so great.